Consider this post a PSA of sorts. It's obvious that you need to practice caution with eBay purchases, BUT (
BIG BUT!), I guess I
still give people too much credit. You'd think after my
Wet n Wild Spring Forward hunt I would know better than to turn to eBay... I'd heard of people selling counterfeit Urban Decay NAKED palettes, but I hadn't seen anything on theBalm Nude ‘tude palette. Well look who got played!
The real palette is on top, the knockoff below.
I was pretty excited I won this palette for $18.49, which is half of the regular price. The description was vague so I figured some girl in Ohio just didn't want it anymore. Ha! I should have been
way more skeptical. The knockoff has a cool, blueish hue, whereas the real one is very warm and brown. The real palette is also thinner and shorter than the knockoff.
The knockoff is actually really impressive, though you can immediately see how blurred and dull the printing is, especially with the photos of the shadow colors.
theBalm Nude ‘tude eyeshadow palette comes in two versions: Naughty and Nice. The only difference being the background images (if they're real), however a lot more is different with these two. The shape of the brush slots vary, with the real one being rectangular, and knockoff much more rounded. The width, length, and color of the ribbon is also inconsistent. Plus, the knockoff is unraveling (lol).
The logo is also quite different! Aside from the illegible "cosmetics" below "theBalm," the real logo has magenta lips.
The brushes are totally different. The real brush has the
actual logo printed in pink, whereas the knockoff couldn't even match the typeface
and it's purple. The length of the real brush is much shorter than the knockoff and the bristles are much longer and rounded on the shadow side. And now to the shadow comparison:
In the pan some of the colors are pretty close, albeit duller, but when swatched it's a totally different story! They're extremely chalky, have almost zero pigmentation and the fallout is out of control. They also kind of stain? Terrible.
Of course it's difficult to see all of these differences online, especially when sellers use other people's photos of the
real product. My advice is to buy the real thing online at
theBalm's website, on
HauteLook where it's offered at 50% off ($18!!), or at Walgreens locations with a Look Boutique like I did. Luckily, I received a full refund thanks to eBay's Buyer Protection and now I have this spare, completely useless palette... If you do risk it and buy from eBay, hopefully this post will help you spot if it's a fake.
UPDATE: theBalm is back on HauteLook today (6/20/14) through Monday (6/23/14) 8AM Pacific! Get this palette for 50% off - only $18!